Uncategorized

donovan mcnabb hall of fame

You might have better numbers, but Aikman was a winner and never panicked (and puked) in the biggest moment of his career… Sorry, your blog cannot share posts by email. DryHeave McNabb how many Rings do you have? Despite a great playoff resume on paper, McNabb … He just had the unfortunate problem of playing on bad teams. In 13 seasons with Philadelphia Eagles, Washington Redskins and Minnesota Vikings, McNabb had a 98-62-1 mark as a starting quarterback, and led the Eagles to five NFC Championship games and one Super Bowl appearance. Matthew Stafford has put up great numbers in Detroit, yet few consider him a Hall of Famer since he was never considered a top-five quarterback despite seven consecutive seasons with 4,000 yards. Too bad McNabb didn’t have a better team around him. There are plenty of QB’s who could have won Super Bowls with those Cowboys teams. cletuspstillwaterjr says: The HOF should be reserved for those without whom the story of the NFL could not be told. Sorry Donovan, running QB’s just don’t… Oh, never mind! "Even these last two years, when people may look at it and say, 'Oh, he's done, or whatever.' And for you “numbers” people….both Aikman and McNabb played in 16 postseason games. But all you need is the “eyeball test”…who looked like a better QB when you were watching them, Aikman or McNabb? To me McNabb is not a HOFer simply because, at NO point in his career was he considered elite or one of the best at his position, no matter what he may say. McNabb is the Most OVER RATED Player in Eagles history! In NO UNIVERSE is DONOVAN MCNABB a Hall Of Famer. He also took the Arizona Cardinals just short of a Super Bowl win. He also NEVER WON A SUPER BOWL. It seems that a QBs legacy is largely determined by luck of the draw where they were drafted. Bad form, son.. i’m a stat guy. If Donovan’s goal was to get people talking, well done. Aikman has 3 rings Kinda sad McNabb is viewed with such disdain. they really do, so that’s how we need to approach this gentleman. ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ ==== But Aikman was at least great in the postseason and that’s why he’s in the Hall of Fame. 176 comments and counting. The team finished 6-10, and McNabb later said that coach Mike Shanahan The other three — Fran Tarkenton, John Elway and Steve Young — all are in the Hall of Fame. College is even worse when awarding the Heisman to the “best player”, which is usually the QB on a top team. My numbers speak for themselves,” McNabb told TMZ. That one was a knee slapper! Right or wrong, Super Bowl rings play an inordinate part in a quarterback’s Hall of Fame candidacy. Aikman was a better leader and yes, Super Bowls do count. Would they have been better? Spot on. Regardless of how you feel about the validity of these claims, the really sad part of this is that McNabb is trying to stand on the shoulder of a legend to make himself look taller. A heckuva career. Tony romo had more touchdowns, better completion percentage and a lot better qb rating. My numbers speak for themselves," McNabb said. He choked in 4 NFC Championship games where the Eagles were Favored to win. His mother should be in the HOF before him, she killed it in those soup commercials. And nobody can ever take it away. Even if you add his rushing yards and TD’s to his passing stats, he’s still not in the elite class in my amateur opinion. That’s what haters do- hate. The regular season has a lot of Hall Of Very Good players. I still remember ESPN, saying Mcnabb was 89% of Eagles offense or some ridiculous number. I still remember the Carolina championship game, where his receivers couldn’t get off the line of scrimmage. Philthy is the worst. Aikman played in an era where defenders were still allowed to defend. What? When McNabb retired in 2011, there were 15 quarterbacks ahead of him in total yards passing. He choked in the Super Bowl and Puked on the field due to being out of shape. couldn’t coexist. He’s not a good guy. Based on regular season, I’m not entirely sure that Aikman deserves to be in the Hall of Fame. Playing 13 seasons, putting up these numbers are not as impressive as they seem. ———————- Donovan McNabb compares himself to Troy Aikman. He wasn’t the most accurate passer, but yes having Emmit and Jay, and Michael made his career, which is why some people argue rings shouldn’t matter. He was a hack that wouldn’t have held on with most teams had he not been paired with Reid. Terrell Davis is 55th (and falling) in career yards. McNabb had 2000 more passing yards, 2400 more rushing yards with 22 more rushing TDs, and 58 fewer ints. Apologies if I missed anyone… and I probably did. Most accurate passer ever. Fate puts a great coach and a great QB together such as Walsh/ Montana or Belichick/ Brady. There are already too many guys in the Hall Of Fame who shouldn’t be there and more than a few who should but aren’t. He faced Brady, Brees x2, Ryan x2, Keenum, and Trubisky (3 or 5 HoF depending on Ryan) McNabb spent 11 years with the Eagles and went to six Pro Bowls, but he never won a Super Bowl, and the list of QBs in the Hall of Fame without a Super Bowl win is not very long — although it does include Moon. I don’t buy into the Super Bowl ring thing. I don’t buy into the Super Bowl ring thing. He averaged about 2,800 yards a season, which today would be considered below average for a franchise quarterback, let alone a Hall of Famer. So stir up all the revisionist history you’d like, in the end that’s what makes what Dallas did so amazing- they won it all and etched their names amoung the best to ever do it. Considering Aikman is probably the most over-rated QB in the HOF after Namath, that’s not saying much. McNabb should be in HOF for the simple fact that Kurt Warner is…he had a good 4 year stretch with a bunch of awful years. It’s not just about the pedestrian stats – yards and completions. Logic like his is why guys who have never won anything (Like Chris Carter) get into the HOF while we debate whether or not Julian Edelman has enough “regular season yardage” to be considered. Super Bowl wins are a TEAM accomplishment. Also, when everything was going great you acted like a clown…always wanting to be the center of attention. SPORTS ILLUSTRATED is a registered trademark of ABG-SI LLC. The delegate from Philadelphia would like to point out and correct that McNabb puked way more than once and we are open to trading him for pretty much anybody. 5 had Westbrook and Owens for one season. McNabb had some Jay Schroeder in his game with all those ground balls he threw. Conversation is over before it begins. So if McNabb is, at best, the 5th or 6th best QB of his era, I wouldn’t call him HOF-worthy…Sorry Donovan. He transcended the game on a historical level, Doolin Danger says: But the reality is that individual players make “teams” more or less successful. It’s all about team work, offense, defense, special teams. (23 in 1992), Oh, McNabb. "And I would vote for myself for the Hall of Fame.". Stop embarrassing Philadelphia!! Troy Aikman didn’t win three Super Bowls – he was a member of a team that did. “Leadership” is a little tougher to measure. The Class of 2021 is his fifth year of eligibility, and he’s never been a finalist. LOL. Aikman also had a relatively short career and never was one of the elite QBs (that would be Young, Favre, and Kelly). Learn how your comment data is processed. So…should Terry H and Cliff be in the HOF debate? —————————————————————– The reason interception numbers have dropped so dramatically in recent years has nothing to do with quarterbacks being better or more accurate, and everything to do with how we’ve neutered defenses. Lots of people have better numbers than Roger Staubach too—who would you rather have on your team??? Hahahahahaha. Spoiler Alert – neither of them should be in either. I’ve never heard Aikman utter one word about himself or his stats except to say the only thing he cared about was winning. Ultimately football is a team sport, if you put any quarterback in NFL history and put him behind David Carr’s line he would’ve had a David Carr career. My numbers are better than Troy Aikman’s. I swear, if there was one thing I could change about sports fans it would be for them to abandon the argument that individual players win championships. He only threw about 2,000 more yards than Jay Cutler who is ranked 28th All-Time and is considered nowhere close to Canton. I’m not a McNabb fan but there is way to much emphasis put on Super Bowls when it comes to the HOF. Knows Eagles fans. And the other star players for the Jets that day were their defensive players, who completely shut down the Colts offense. Namath got in and his stats are terrible. One thing you should have learned is opening your mouth only delays any HOF nods. Wentz will be the best QB this team has ever had and all the Eagles fans know it. You may recall that Aikman also went to 4 straight NFCCGs I still remember a play against Detroit. I’m not saying he’s definitely HOF but he’s got an argument. McNabb is good, but not even in the same conversation with Aikman. —– Shall we put Dilfer in since he was a SB winning QB? Aikman was more accurate than Brees. McNabb made his argument to TMZ and focused his candidacy on one player. Let others pick you. Donovan has always been misunderstood outside of Philly.

Highest Elevation Stadium In The World, Robot Chicken Season 11, Who Owns Neutrog, Batman Beyond: Return Of The Joker N64, Insomnia Definition, Sarah Carter Age, The Mixed Tape Lyrics, Australia World Cup 2006, Alison Wheeler Husband, Scapin The Schemer, Ovechkin Contract End, Facts About The Grimm Brothers, House Of Blues, Dte Report Power Outage, Onyx Corporation, 60064 Zip Code, Bolivia Football League Table, Gold And Braid Stevie Nicks Chords, Johnson And Johnson Toronto, Cinema Vérité Vs Direct Cinema, Taylor Lacher Cause Of Death, My Name Is Joe Meme, Dr Rodney Tyson, Stalley Net Worth, Austria-hungary Ww1 Leader, Heather Watson Obituary Massachusetts, Blood On The Leaves, First Stage Approval Spousal Sponsorship, Richard Gasquet Wife, Red's Dream Theme, Jessica Blair Herman Religion, Rebecca Sparknotes, One Thousand And One Nights Aladdin, Siemens Product Sales Executive Salary, Pg&e Power Outage Today, Kati Cameron, Oh My Love My Darling Lyrics, Kell Brook,